› ›

CNC Mode Arc Direction Problem

yilmazyurdakulyilmazyurdakul
edited March 2021 in Bug Reports
Hi

I am using my machine in CNC mode. Sometimes arcs goes wrong direction. 
In this picture i was cutting robotic arm. circles are true. Outer cutting direction gone wrong. CNC made a circle without any reason. I guess two half circle become a circle. 

https://ibb.co/x325y9n

This is gcode from fusion 360

(A3)
(Machine)
(  vendor: yyCustom)
(  description: Cub3 First)
(T1  D=4 CR=0 - ZMIN=-10 - flat end mill)
G90 G94
G17
G21

(2D Contour2)
T1
S12000 M3
G54
M8
G0 Z15
G0 X166.308 Y19.755
G0
G0 Z5
G1 Z4.5 F100
G1 Z-3.1
G1 X166.316 Z-3.178 F300.1
G1 X166.338 Z-3.253
G1 X166.375 Y19.756 Z-3.322
G1 X166.425 Y19.758 Z-3.383
G1 X166.486 Y19.759 Z-3.433
G1 X166.555 Y19.761 Z-3.47
G1 X166.63 Y19.763 Z-3.492
G1 X166.708 Y19.765 Z-3.5
G1 X167.108 Y19.774
G3 X167.498 Y20.184 I-0.01 J0.4
G3 X152.502 Y19.816 I-7.498 J-0.184
G3 X167.498 Y20.184 I7.498 J0.184
G3 X167.088 Y20.574 I-0.4 J-0.01
G1 X166.688 Y20.564
G1 X166.61 Y20.562 Z-3.492
G1 X166.535 Y20.561 Z-3.47
G1 X166.466 Y20.559 Z-3.433
G1 X166.405 Y20.557 Z-3.383
G1 X166.356 Y20.556 Z-3.322
G1 X166.319 Y20.555 Z-3.253
G1 X166.296 Z-3.178
G1 X166.288 Y20.554 Z-3.1
G1 X166.308 Y19.755
G1 Z-6.6 F100
G1 X166.316 Z-6.678 F300.1
G1 X166.338 Z-6.753
G1 X166.375 Y19.756 Z-6.822
G1 X166.425 Y19.758 Z-6.883
G1 X166.486 Y19.759 Z-6.933
G1 X166.555 Y19.761 Z-6.97
G1 X166.63 Y19.763 Z-6.992
G1 X166.708 Y19.765 Z-7
G1 X167.108 Y19.774
G3 X167.498 Y20.184 I-0.01 J0.4
G3 X152.502 Y19.816 I-7.498 J-0.184
G3 X167.498 Y20.184 I7.498 J0.184
G3 X167.088 Y20.574 I-0.4 J-0.01
G1 X166.688 Y20.564
G1 X166.61 Y20.562 Z-6.992
G1 X166.535 Y20.561 Z-6.97
G1 X166.466 Y20.559 Z-6.933
G1 X166.405 Y20.557 Z-6.883
G1 X166.356 Y20.556 Z-6.822
G1 X166.319 Y20.555 Z-6.753
G1 X166.296 Z-6.678
G1 X166.288 Y20.554 Z-6.6
G1 X166.308 Y19.755
G1 Z-9.6 F100
G1 X166.316 Z-9.678 F300.1
G1 X166.338 Z-9.753
G1 X166.375 Y19.756 Z-9.822
G1 X166.425 Y19.758 Z-9.883
G1 X166.486 Y19.759 Z-9.933
G1 X166.555 Y19.761 Z-9.97
G1 X166.63 Y19.763 Z-9.992
G1 X166.708 Y19.765 Z-10
G1 X167.108 Y19.774
G3 X167.498 Y20.184 I-0.01 J0.4
G3 X152.502 Y19.816 I-7.498 J-0.184
G3 X167.498 Y20.184 I7.498 J0.184
G3 X167.088 Y20.574 I-0.4 J-0.01
G1 X166.688 Y20.564
G1 X166.61 Y20.562 Z-9.992
G1 X166.535 Y20.561 Z-9.97
G1 X166.466 Y20.559 Z-9.933
G1 X166.405 Y20.557 Z-9.883
G1 X166.356 Y20.556 Z-9.822
G1 X166.319 Y20.555 Z-9.753
G1 X166.296 Z-9.678
G1 X166.288 Y20.554 Z-9.6
G0 Z10
G0 X216.3 Y19.6
G0 Z5
G1 Z4.5 F100
G1 Z-3.1
G18 G2 X216.7 Z-3.5 I0.4 K0 F300.1
G1 X217.1
G17 G3 X217.5 Y20 I0 J0.4
G3 X202.5 Y20 I-7.5 J0
G3 X217.5 Y20 I7.5 J0
G3 X217.1 Y20.4 I-0.4 J0
G1 X216.7
G18 G3 X216.3 Z-3.1 I0 K0.4
G1 Y19.6
G1 Z-6.6 F100
G2 X216.7 Z-7 I0.4 K0 F300.1
G1 X217.1
G17 G3 X217.5 Y20 I0 J0.4
G3 X202.5 Y20 I-7.5 J0
G3 X217.5 Y20 I7.5 J0
G3 X217.1 Y20.4 I-0.4 J0
G1 X216.7
G18 G3 X216.3 Z-6.6 I0 K0.4
G1 Y19.6
G1 Z-9.6 F100
G2 X216.7 Z-10 I0.4 K0 F300.1
G1 X217.1
G17 G3 X217.5 Y20 I0 J0.4
G3 X202.5 Y20 I-7.5 J0
G3 X217.5 Y20 I7.5 J0
G3 X217.1 Y20.4 I-0.4 J0
G1 X216.7
G18 G3 X216.3 Z-9.6 I0 K0.4
G0 Z10
G0 X239.7 Y13.2
G0 Z5
G1 Z4.5 F100
G1 Z-3.1
G19 G2 Y12.8 Z-3.5 J-0.4 K0 F300.1
G1 Y12.4
G17 G3 X240.1 Y12 I0.4 J0
G1 X268.1
G1 Y28
G1 X232.1
G1 Y12
G1 X240.1
G3 X240.5 Y12.4 I0 J0.4
G1 Y12.8
G19 G3 Y13.2 Z-3.1 J0 K0.4
G1 X239.7
G1 Z-6.6 F100
G2 Y12.8 Z-7 J-0.4 K0 F300.1
G1 Y12.4
G17 G3 X240.1 Y12 I0.4 J0
G1 X268.1
G1 Y28
G1 X232.1
G1 Y12
G1 X240.1
G3 X240.5 Y12.4 I0 J0.4
G1 Y12.8
G19 G3 Y13.2 Z-6.6 J0 K0.4
G1 X239.7
G1 Z-9.6 F100
G2 Y12.8 Z-10 J-0.4 K0 F300.1
G1 Y12.4
G17 G3 X240.1 Y12 I0.4 J0
G1 X268.1
G1 Y28
G1 X232.1
G1 Y12
G1 X240.1
G3 X240.5 Y12.4 I0 J0.4
G1 Y12.8
G19 G3 Y13.2 Z-9.6 J0 K0.4
G0 Z10
G0 X116.308 Y19.755
G0 Z5
G1 Z4.5 F100
G1 Z-3.1
G1 X116.316 Z-3.178 F300.1
G1 X116.338 Z-3.253
G1 X116.375 Y19.756 Z-3.322
G1 X116.425 Y19.758 Z-3.383
G1 X116.486 Y19.759 Z-3.433
G1 X116.555 Y19.761 Z-3.47
G1 X116.63 Y19.763 Z-3.492
G1 X116.708 Y19.765 Z-3.5
G1 X117.108 Y19.774
G17 G3 X117.498 Y20.184 I-0.01 J0.4
G3 X102.502 Y19.816 I-7.498 J-0.184
G3 X117.498 Y20.184 I7.498 J0.184
G3 X117.088 Y20.574 I-0.4 J-0.01
G1 X116.688 Y20.564
G1 X116.61 Y20.562 Z-3.492
G1 X116.535 Y20.561 Z-3.47
G1 X116.466 Y20.559 Z-3.433
G1 X116.405 Y20.557 Z-3.383
G1 X116.356 Y20.556 Z-3.322
G1 X116.319 Y20.555 Z-3.253
G1 X116.296 Z-3.178
G1 X116.288 Y20.554 Z-3.1
G1 X116.308 Y19.755
G1 Z-6.6 F100
G1 X116.316 Z-6.678 F300.1
G1 X116.338 Z-6.753
G1 X116.375 Y19.756 Z-6.822
G1 X116.425 Y19.758 Z-6.883
G1 X116.486 Y19.759 Z-6.933
G1 X116.555 Y19.761 Z-6.97
G1 X116.63 Y19.763 Z-6.992
G1 X116.708 Y19.765 Z-7
G1 X117.108 Y19.774
G3 X117.498 Y20.184 I-0.01 J0.4
G3 X102.502 Y19.816 I-7.498 J-0.184
G3 X117.498 Y20.184 I7.498 J0.184
G3 X117.088 Y20.574 I-0.4 J-0.01
G1 X116.688 Y20.564
G1 X116.61 Y20.562 Z-6.992
G1 X116.535 Y20.561 Z-6.97
G1 X116.466 Y20.559 Z-6.933
G1 X116.405 Y20.557 Z-6.883
G1 X116.356 Y20.556 Z-6.822
G1 X116.319 Y20.555 Z-6.753
G1 X116.296 Z-6.678
G1 X116.288 Y20.554 Z-6.6
G1 X116.308 Y19.755
G1 Z-9.6 F100
G1 X116.316 Z-9.678 F300.1
G1 X116.338 Z-9.753
G1 X116.375 Y19.756 Z-9.822
G1 X116.425 Y19.758 Z-9.883
G1 X116.486 Y19.759 Z-9.933
G1 X116.555 Y19.761 Z-9.97
G1 X116.63 Y19.763 Z-9.992
G1 X116.708 Y19.765 Z-10
G1 X117.108 Y19.774
G3 X117.498 Y20.184 I-0.01 J0.4
G3 X102.502 Y19.816 I-7.498 J-0.184
G3 X117.498 Y20.184 I7.498 J0.184
G3 X117.088 Y20.574 I-0.4 J-0.01
G1 X116.688 Y20.564
G1 X116.61 Y20.562 Z-9.992
G1 X116.535 Y20.561 Z-9.97
G1 X116.466 Y20.559 Z-9.933
G1 X116.405 Y20.557 Z-9.883
G1 X116.356 Y20.556 Z-9.822
G1 X116.319 Y20.555 Z-9.753
G1 X116.296 Z-9.678
G1 X116.288 Y20.554 Z-9.6
G0 Z10
G0 X66.3 Y19.6
G0 Z5
G1 Z4.5 F100
G1 Z-3.1
G18 G2 X66.7 Z-3.5 I0.4 K0 F300.1
G1 X67.1
G17 G3 X67.5 Y20 I0 J0.4
G3 X52.5 Y20 I-7.5 J0
G3 X67.5 Y20 I7.5 J0
G3 X67.1 Y20.4 I-0.4 J0
G1 X66.7
G18 G3 X66.3 Z-3.1 I0 K0.4
G1 Y19.6
G1 Z-6.6 F100
G2 X66.7 Z-7 I0.4 K0 F300.1
G1 X67.1
G17 G3 X67.5 Y20 I0 J0.4
G3 X52.5 Y20 I-7.5 J0
G3 X67.5 Y20 I7.5 J0
G3 X67.1 Y20.4 I-0.4 J0
G1 X66.7
G18 G3 X66.3 Z-6.6 I0 K0.4
G1 Y19.6
G1 Z-9.6 F100
G2 X66.7 Z-10 I0.4 K0 F300.1
G1 X67.1
G17 G3 X67.5 Y20 I0 J0.4
G3 X52.5 Y20 I-7.5 J0
G3 X67.5 Y20 I7.5 J0
G3 X67.1 Y20.4 I-0.4 J0
G1 X66.7
G18 G3 X66.3 Z-9.6 I0 K0.4
G0 Z10
G0 X19.8 Y19.6
G0 Z5
G1 Z4.5 F100
G1 Z-3.1
G2 X20.2 Z-3.5 I0.4 K0 F300.1
G1 X20.6
G17 G3 X21 Y20 I0 J0.4
G3 X19 Y20 I-1 J0
G3 X21 Y20 I1 J0
G3 X20.6 Y20.4 I-0.4 J0
G1 X20.2
G18 G3 X19.8 Z-3.1 I0 K0.4
G1 Y19.6
G1 Z-6.6 F100
G2 X20.2 Z-7 I0.4 K0 F300.1
G1 X20.6
G17 G3 X21 Y20 I0 J0.4
G3 X19 Y20 I-1 J0
G3 X21 Y20 I1 J0
G3 X20.6 Y20.4 I-0.4 J0
G1 X20.2
G18 G3 X19.8 Z-6.6 I0 K0.4
G1 Y19.6
G1 Z-9.6 F100
G2 X20.2 Z-10 I0.4 K0 F300.1
G1 X20.6
G17 G3 X21 Y20 I0 J0.4
G3 X19 Y20 I-1 J0
G3 X21 Y20 I1 J0
G3 X20.6 Y20.4 I-0.4 J0
G1 X20.2
G18 G3 X19.8 Z-9.6 I0 K0.4
G0 Z15
G17

Problem Starts Here!

(2D Contour2 2)
G0 Z15
G0 X19.6 Y43.2
G0 Z5
G1 Z4.5 F100
G1 Z-3.1
G19 G2 Y42.8 Z-3.5 J-0.4 K0 F300.1
G1 Y42.4
G17 G3 X20 Y42 I0.4 J0
G1 X260
G2 X260 Y-2 I0 J-22
G1 X20
G2 X20 Y42 I0 J22
G3 X20.4 Y42.4 I0 J0.4
G1 Y42.8
G19 G3 Y43.2 Z-3.1 J0 K0.4
G1 X19.6
G1 Z-6.6 F100
G2 Y42.8 Z-7 J-0.4 K0 F300.1
G1 Y42.4
G17 G3 X20 Y42 I0.4 J0
G1 X260
G2 X260 Y-2 I0 J-22
G1 X20
G2 X20 Y42 I0 J22
G3 X20.4 Y42.4 I0 J0.4
G1 Y42.8
G19 G3 Y43.2 Z-6.6 J0 K0.4
G1 X19.6
G1 Z-9.6 F100
G2 Y42.8 Z-10 J-0.4 K0 F300.1
G1 Y42.4
G17 G3 X20 Y42 I0.4 J0
G1 X260
G2 X260 Y-2 I0 J-22
G1 X20
G2 X20 Y42 I0 J22
G3 X20.4 Y42.4 I0 J0.4
G1 Y42.8
G19 G3 Y43.2 Z-9.6 J0 K0.4
G0 Z15
G17
M9
M5
M30

Thanks

Comments

  • yilmazyurdakulyilmazyurdakul
    I just realized some j values are negative in last part. Maybe that could be helpful
  • yilmazyurdakulyilmazyurdakul
    I solved. 

    1 - I send M453 to switch CNC mode
    2 - Zero all axes. 
    3 - Set virtual home position according to workpiece.
    4 - I realized there were no space on Y axis  to move backwards. I left Y axis at real home position.
    5 - I moved Y a little bit away from home position. 
    6 - It works perfect!
    7 - Repetier is the best.
  • RepetierRepetier
    Thanks. I already had a look and did not see any errors in gcode. Negative y is of course a problem if not allowed.
    G1 S1
    would also disable position check in case you need to disable it e.g. for negative Z. But I think in cnc mode that is allowed anyway.
  • yilmazyurdakulyilmazyurdakul
    Yes, It allows negative directions but problem was silly. There were no enough physicals space to move. Thanks. Maybe this post will help someone else
Sign In or Register to comment.